*** Ross Rant ***
Carr speaks. Jimmy sits.
A comedian makes social commentary. A government official threatens action. A network pulls the plug. This isn’t a story from Moscow or Beijing—it’s what just happened to Jimmy Kimmel, right here in the United States.
ABC took Kimmel off the air after Brendan Carr, chair of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), floated the idea that the network could be punished for Kimmel’s remarks. Carr, on a conservative podcast, said Kimmel’s comments were part of a “concerted effort to lie to the American people.” Hours later, ABC folded. The Walt Disney Company, which owns ABC, put keeping a regulator happy ahead of protecting free speech.
This kind of quick surrender should set off alarms for anyone who cares about open debate and free speech.
When government threats can silence comedians, we cross a line that the First Amendment was built to stop. The First Amendment, which protects free speech, exists to keep government intimidation out of the public square.
But the story doesn’t stop there.
Nexstar, which owns local TV stations across the country, joined in. Nexstar announced it would drop Kimmel’s show from its ABC-affiliated stations. Why would Nexstar back government censorship? The answer is simple: money.
Nexstar wants to merge with Tegna, another big media company. That deal needs the FCC’s sign-off. By pulling Kimmel, Nexstar sent a clear signal to Carr: We’ll play ball if you approve our merger. This is what happens when regulatory power warps the market for ideas.
Let’s break this down.
A comedian is commenting on the state of affairs. A government official doesn’t like them. Companies that need government approval silence the comedian. This chain of events would fit right in with strongman politics overseas. It should outrage Americans.
The danger here is bigger than any one show.
If the FCC can shut down speech it doesn’t like, who draws the line? Today it’s Kimmel. Tomorrow it could be any journalist, commentator, or critic. When we let government officials punish speech they dislike, we lose what makes America different from less free countries.
Business leaders should take note. Companies that bow to pressure on speech turn into tools for censorship. They trade their backbone for a shot at regulatory favors—this kind of deal poisons both business and democracy.
Look at the timing. Carr speaks. Companies scramble. Shows vanish. This isn’t how free markets or free speech work. This is fear in action. When business decisions hinge on regulatory threats, rather than audience choice or company values, the market breaks down.
We’ve seen this before in other countries. Officials target critics. Businesses fall in line to protect deals or licenses. Independent voices go quiet. Democracy weakens. America is supposed to be different. The Constitution is supposed to stop this. Yet we’re watching it play out.
The answer is simple, but not easy: courage.
Media companies must stand up to regulatory threats. Business leaders must call out government censorship, even if it’s risky. Citizens must demand that regulators focus on their real jobs, not policing late-night jokes. Most of all, we must protect the speech we dislike, not just the speech we agree with.
Once the government gets to decide which jokes are allowed, we’ve already lost the bigger fight for freedom.
-Marc
*** A11. ***
The unlikely personal friendship between Trump and Starmer: The British prime minister has gone out of his way to make the US president feel heard. Politico
Trump affirms ‘immortal bonds’ after royal treatment in UK: WP reports the trip, filled with pomp and pageantry, began with a parade on the grounds of Windsor Castle and concluded with business deals and talk of trade.
Trump and Starmer, skirting differences, praise each other in UK: The Republican US president and the Labour British prime minister appear to have formed a friendship, however unlikely. NYT
Trump, Starmer paper over cracks amid royal pageantry: WSJ reports the two leaders projected unity despite differences over Palestinian statehood, immigration, and energy policy.
Politico: Starmer and Trump's united front cracks on subject of Russia-Ukraine war
Where has the state visit left the US-UK relationship? President Trump and the prime minister were not aligned on all issues, but Starmer will be relieved to have avoided public humiliation at Chequers. The Times
The UK must stand up to Trump’s tech regulation pressure: Caving in to US demands on digital tax and content moderation would be an economic and political mistake. José Ignacio Torreblanca
Trump says US ‘trying’ to get Bagram airbase back: Politico reports the first Trump administration negotiated an American withdrawal from the country by 2021 and didn’t mention keeping the base.
Donald Trump says Afghanistan’s Bagram air base should be returned to US control: FT reports president says site is strategic due to its proximity to China.
Today: Trump has a phone call with Xi Jinping this morning at 9:00 am ET.
Trump nixed $400 million in Taiwan military aid, pushing future arms sales: WP reports the president declined to approve a package of weapons to Taiwan this summer, as he tries to negotiate a trade deal and a potential summit with Chinese leader Xi Jinping.
‘Russian spies’ arrested in Essex suspected of tracking dissidents: The Times reports the Met Police confirmed three suspects were held on suspicion of assisting the Kremlin’s intelligence service.
UK urged to do more to protect undersea cables from attack: The Times reports security committee of MPs and peers says government is ‘too timid’ about risk of ‘catastrophic disruption’ caused by hostile powers such as Russia.
Thailand-Cambodia ceasefire is ‘fragile bandage over a long-festering wound’: The Times reports that the war in Southeast Asia stopped seven weeks ago, tensions are still simmering, and it appears to be a matter of when, not if, full-scale violence erupts again.
How Israel is dismantling the dream of a Palestinian state: While attention has been focused on Gaza, Israel has undermined the delicate architecture of governance in the West Bank built up over three decades. FT
How Israel is losing America: Public opinion is souring even in Israel’s strongest ally. Israelis should worry. Economist
Reuters: UAE could downgrade diplomatic ties if Israel annexes West Bank, sources say
Saudi Arabia seeks new security alliances as trust in US erodes: WSJ reports the kingdom signed a new defense pact with Pakistan a week after Israel carried out a missile attack targeting Hamas political officials in Qatar, another key US Arab Gulf partner.
Giorgia Meloni to bring back holiday honouring ‘the first Italian’: The Times reports an extra day off to celebrate St Francis of Assisi would ‘complete Italy’s identity’, says the prime minister’s party, but it will cost the country millions.
The Argentine Church ramps up criticism of President Javier Milei's austerity measures: Le Monde reports that, from priests working in shantytowns to bishops, representatives of the institution have condemned the government's budget cuts.
Trump’s trade war split Canada and Mexico. Now they want a united front. WSJ reports America’s top two trading partners are seeking a strategic partnership ahead of negotiations with the US over tariffs.
Gatekeepers and national traumas: In 1963, hardly anyone saw the Zapruder film. It was kept from the public by the media’s responsible men. Peggy Noonan
Trump administration wields its full toolbox to bring media to heel: ABC’s decision to “indefinitely” suspend Jimmy Kimmel’s late-night talk show illuminates the administration’s efficacy so far. NYT
NYT: President says broadcasters risk losing licenses when hosts criticize him
Bloomberg: Kimmel’s suspension is latest victory in Trump war on media
Canceling Jimmy Kimmel: FCC Chairman Brendan Carr thinks he’s a showrunner for late-night comedy. He used to know better. WP-Editorial
When free speech evangelists lose the plot: Charlie Kirk’s deplorable murder has sent Republican hypocrisy on the subject rocketing. Robert Shrimsley
Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension raises fears of a new censorship era: WP reports critics accused ABC of bowing to President Donald Trump after it suspended Kimmel’s show over his remarks about the suspect in the Charlie Kirk killing.
Inside Disney’s abrupt decision to suspend Jimmy Kimmel’s show: The late-night host wanted to address the firestorm over his remarks about Charlie Kirk’s killing on Wednesday’s show. Company leaders worried it would make matters worse. WSJ
The FCC threatened to punish Kimmel ‘the hard way.’ ABC made it easy. Another media company caved after pressure from a Trump official, and the chilling effect got a few degrees colder. NYT
What is Disney thinking? By pulling Jimmy Kimmel off the air, Bob Iger risks tarnishing his legacy in Hollywood. Josef Adalian
Disney capitulation over Jimmy Kimmel sparks fears for US media under Donald Trump: Bob Iger’s suspension of comedian’s show over Charlie Kirk comments fuels free speech controversy. FT
The clear and present danger to the First Amendment: America's commitment to free speech depends on an understanding of the constitutional provision that protects it. Jessica Karl
David Letterman says Kimmel’s suspension is ‘just not how this works’: NYT reports: “We all see where this is going,” the longtime late-night host said of ABC’s move to suspend Jimmy Kimmel’s talk show after pressure from the Trump administration.
Inside the room where CEOs say what they really think of Trump’s policies: America’s top executives are expressing worry about moves that many see as state capitalism and pressure on the Fed. WSJ
American farmers are feeling the pain of Trump’s policies: US agricultural communities that had expected Trump to have their backs have found themselves flung into a second trade war. If the situation continues, it could put loyalties at risk. Bloomberg
CNN: Former Biden chief of staff Jeff Zients testifies in probe of Biden mental decline
Harris' score-settling, elbow-throwing, bridge-burning memoir: The former vice president’s reflection on the 2024 campaign includes pointed anecdotes about likely 2028 contenders. Politico
In ‘107 Days,’ Kamala Harris lays out her regrets: In her book, coming out next week, she revisited her breakneck campaign, explaining her choices and outlining missteps — of hers and others. She hinted at a return to politics. NYT
Harris book draws blowback from Shapiro, Buttigieg. Here’s what’s in it. The same people criticizing what she said about them in her new book about the 2024 campaign could be among those she faces in 2028 if she runs again. WP
ICE seeks hundreds of new offices to house 10,000 additional staffers: WP reports officials are looking for roughly 300 new sites to support plans to hire thousands of new deportation officers and lawyers.
21%: The approximate share of FBI agents that Donald Trump has diverted to do the work of ICE.
FTC sues Ticketmaster alleging illegal Tticket resale tactics: WSJ reports Ticketmaster is accused of illegal tactics that cost consumers billions of dollars.
Nvidia to invest $5 billion in Intel, furthering Trump’s turnaround plan: WSJ reports the investment pairs the world’s most valuable company, which has been a darling of the AI boom, with a chip maker that has fallen behind rivals.
DeepMind hails ‘Kasparov moment’ as AI beats best human coders: The Times reports Google beat 135 human teams at the ‘coding Olympics’, marking a profound leap for AI comparable to chess grandmaster’s defeat to a computer.
AI models must adapt or die: The technology has already consumed almost all high-quality data — experience is now the dominant medium of improvement. John Thornhill
Since leaving Washington, Elon Musk has been all in on his AI company: NYT reports Musk spent the summer at his artificial intelligence start-up xAI, trying to match the runaway success of OpenAI. The result was chaos.
The $4trn accounting puzzle at the heart of the AI cloud: A bean counter’s look at the hyperscalers’ balance sheets.Economist
Antarctica's tourism boom accelerates melting of 'white continent': While the number of tourists has skyrocketed over the past decade, the pristine continent, which is attracting growing interest among researchers, is gradually deteriorating. Le Monde
Stone-skimming championship in Scotland gets rocked by cheating scandal: CBC reports organizers say the stones in question were 'suspiciously round'
TA: Clayton Kershaw, Dodgers icon, is retiring after 18 seasons
Enjoy the ride + plan accordingly.
-Marc
Marc A. Ross | Chief Communications Strategist @ Caracal
A11. | September 19
